{ "representative_order": [ "03", "06", "07" ], "representatives": [ { "id": "03", "label": "03 · GPT-6 Astra / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第1次", "model": "GPT-6 Astra", "model_id": "gpt-6-astra", "effort": "xhigh", "mode": "Standard", "configuration": "astra-standard", "repetition": 1, "started_at": "2026-10-03T12:40:39.672000+08:00", "completed_at": "2026-10-03T13:08:02.121000+08:00", "wall_time_seconds": 1642.449, "wall_time_display": "27:22", "adjusted_reference_seconds": 1642.449, "adjusted_reference_display": "27:22", "excluded_failed_request_seconds": 0, "responses": 20, "request_attempts": 20, "stream_retries": 0, "service_tier": "default", "input_tokens": 1228210, "cached_input_tokens": 1159936, "uncached_input_tokens": 68274, "output_tokens": 35865, "reasoning_output_tokens": 11449, "total_tokens": 1264075, "cache_hit_pct": 94.44117862580504, "largest_request_input_tokens": 87611, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "standard_equivalent_usd": 3.635926, "purchased_usd_equivalent": 3.635926, "subscription_usd_weight_equivalent": 3.635926, "purchased_credits_equivalent": 90.89815, "subscription_credits_weight_equivalent": 90.89815, "selected_as_configuration_representative": true, "representative_quality_rank": 1, "scene": "scenes/03.html", "source": "code-sources/03.js", "code_review": "code-review/03.html", "sources_directory": "sources/03/", "screenshots": [ "evidence/03-default-03s.png", "evidence/03-wide.png", "evidence/03-close.png" ], "three_revision": "180", "route": "开放河岸，64m周期运动与场景复用", "scarf": "两条36段×横向4段，185顶点/条", "tail": "细致锥形尾巴与姿态动画", "creatures": { "butterflies": 7, "birds": 4, "ducks": 5 }, "wheel_outer_radius": 0.607, "wheel_rolling_divisor": 0.607, "wheel_theoretical_angular_overrotation_pct": 0.0, "draw_calls_at_3s": 471, "triangles_at_3s": 2337708, "quality": { "visual": "角色表情、车辆、包裹和河岸层次最完整，近景仍能看到分段关节。", "motion": "轮转使用正确外半径，踏板与腿部协调；围巾有横向形变。", "environment": "桥、邮局、花草、7只蝴蝶、4只鸟、5只鸭；黄昏、环境音、明信片和隐藏界面。", "selection": "选为Astra代表及三个代表中的第1。渲染三角形最多，精细程度与渲染负担同时存在。" } }, { "id": "06", "label": "06 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第2次", "model": "GPT-6.1 Sol", "model_id": "gpt-6.1-sol", "effort": "xhigh", "mode": "Standard", "configuration": "sol-standard", "repetition": 2, "started_at": "2026-10-03T13:56:11.901000+08:00", "completed_at": "2026-10-03T14:29:45.124000+08:00", "wall_time_seconds": 2013.223, "wall_time_display": "33:33", "adjusted_reference_seconds": 1381.6341764431, "adjusted_reference_display": "23:02", "excluded_failed_request_seconds": 631.5888235569, "responses": 20, "request_attempts": 21, "stream_retries": 1, "service_tier": "default", "input_tokens": 1394820, "cached_input_tokens": 1313920, "uncached_input_tokens": 80900, "output_tokens": 33793, "reasoning_output_tokens": 9200, "total_tokens": 1428613, "cache_hit_pct": 94.199968454711, "largest_request_input_tokens": 95329, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "standard_equivalent_usd": 0.631122, "purchased_usd_equivalent": 0.631122, "subscription_usd_weight_equivalent": 0.631122, "purchased_credits_equivalent": 15.778049999999999, "subscription_credits_weight_equivalent": 15.778049999999999, "selected_as_configuration_representative": true, "representative_quality_rank": 2, "scene": "scenes/06.html", "source": "code-sources/06.html", "code_review": "code-review/06.html", "sources_directory": "sources/06/", "screenshots": [ "evidence/06-default-03s.png", "evidence/06-wide.png", "evidence/06-close.png" ], "three_revision": "160.1", "route": "完整闭合河岸路线，弧长查表", "scarf": "两条36段×横向2段，条纹与流苏", "tail": "锥形固定曲线与姿态", "creatures": { "butterflies": 0, "birds": 6, "ducks": 7 }, "wheel_outer_radius": 0.671, "wheel_rolling_divisor": 0.671, "wheel_theoretical_angular_overrotation_pct": 0.0, "draw_calls_at_3s": 506, "triangles_at_3s": 794072, "quality": { "visual": "角色有表情，编织车篮、花、包裹绳和围巾细节丰富；近景关节接缝仍可见。", "motion": "约170.82m闭合路线，弧长查表控制进度；轮转外半径一致，多圈检查连续。", "environment": "桥、邮局、船、6只拍翼鸟、7只鸭；黄昏、环境音、留影和三视角；没有蝴蝶。", "selection": "选为Sol标准代表及三个代表中的第2；用时的长失败请求不计入质量排名。" } }, { "id": "07", "label": "07 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Fast · 第3次", "model": "GPT-6.1 Sol", "model_id": "gpt-6.1-sol", "effort": "xhigh", "mode": "Fast", "configuration": "sol-fast", "repetition": 3, "started_at": "2026-10-03T14:30:01.840000+08:00", "completed_at": "2026-10-03T14:46:04.077000+08:00", "wall_time_seconds": 962.237, "wall_time_display": "16:02", "adjusted_reference_seconds": 962.237, "adjusted_reference_display": "16:02", "excluded_failed_request_seconds": 0, "responses": 26, "request_attempts": 26, "stream_retries": 0, "service_tier": "priority", "input_tokens": 1721842, "cached_input_tokens": 1646848, "uncached_input_tokens": 74994, "output_tokens": 40929, "reasoning_output_tokens": 12932, "total_tokens": 1762771, "cache_hit_pct": 95.64454810603993, "largest_request_input_tokens": 93754, "cache_write_input_tokens": 0, "standard_equivalent_usd": 0.7239628, "purchased_usd_equivalent": 1.4479256, "subscription_usd_weight_equivalent": 1.809907, "purchased_credits_equivalent": 36.19814, "subscription_credits_weight_equivalent": 45.247675, "selected_as_configuration_representative": true, "representative_quality_rank": 3, "scene": "scenes/07.html", "source": "code-sources/07.js", "code_review": "code-review/07.html", "sources_directory": "sources/07/", "screenshots": [ "evidence/07-default-03s.png", "evidence/07-wide.png", "evidence/07-close.png" ], "three_revision": "160.1", "route": "直线背景滚动，水獭位置基本固定", "scarf": "两条40段×横向6段，287顶点/条；织纹与7条流苏", "tail": "24×14连续锥形尾巴形变", "creatures": { "butterflies": 4, "birds": 0, "ducks": 4 }, "wheel_outer_radius": 0.593, "wheel_rolling_divisor": 0.55, "wheel_theoretical_angular_overrotation_pct": 7.818181818181813, "draw_calls_at_3s": 375, "triangles_at_3s": 390936, "quality": { "visual": "暖秋配色协调，角色、包裹和布料呈现较好；局部球形关节可见。", "motion": "围巾具有横向卷曲，尾巴持续形变。轮转半径0.55小于外半径0.593，理论角速度偏大约7.82%。", "environment": "桥、房屋、船、4只蝴蝶、4只鸭；没有飞鸟、前篮、黄昏和照片导出；相机按钮用于换视角。", "selection": "选为Fast代表及三个代表中的第3。布料、尾巴和低渲染负担有优势；路线、互动和运动精度仍有差距。" } } ], "method": "主体比例与材质、环境/功能、运动/连接正确性、代码及资源负担综合观察；时间、成本和瞬间拍摄遮挡不参与质量排序。无伪精确总分，接近项与优势/不足分别保留。", "all_trial_assessments": [ { "id": "01", "label": "01 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Fast · 第1次", "quality": { "visual": "水獭与车辆可辨，较多球形分段关节；场景和配色较简单。", "motion": "脚部跟随踏板，围巾连续变形。轮胎外半径0.827，滚动使用0.76，理论角速度偏大约8.82%。", "environment": "河流、桥、植被与6只鸭；没有飞鸟和蝴蝶。", "selection": "核心任务完成，三次Fast中最快；最终选07，侧重更协调的视觉、布料和尾巴。" } }, { "id": "02", "label": "02 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第1次", "quality": { "visual": "车篮、雏菊和包裹细节完整，比例清楚。", "motion": "踏板跟随与围巾形变完整；弯曲背景持续滚动。", "environment": "4只蝴蝶、7只鸟、3只鸭；日落、留影和视角切换。", "selection": "绘制调用少，蝴蝶和环境细节是优势；最终选06，角色表达和完整环河运动更合适。" } }, { "id": "03", "label": "03 · GPT-6 Astra / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第1次", "quality": { "visual": "角色表情、车辆、包裹和河岸层次最完整，近景仍能看到分段关节。", "motion": "轮转使用正确外半径，踏板与腿部协调；围巾有横向形变。", "environment": "桥、邮局、花草、7只蝴蝶、4只鸟、5只鸭；黄昏、环境音、明信片和隐藏界面。", "selection": "选为Astra代表及三个代表中的第1。渲染三角形最多，精细程度与渲染负担同时存在。" } }, { "id": "04", "label": "04 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Fast · 第2次", "quality": { "visual": "场景更丰富，有风车、柳树和9只鸭；肢体分段仍明显。", "motion": "围巾和尾巴连续变形。轮转半径0.586小于外半径0.642，理论角速度偏大约9.56%。", "environment": "7只V形轮廓鸟整体移动，没有关节拍翼；风力、黄昏、留影等交互比07更丰富。", "selection": "最终选07，侧重视觉和布料/尾巴的细腻程度；04的额外交互更丰富，不能用单一维度断言完全落后。" } }, { "id": "05", "label": "05 · GPT-6 Astra / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第2次", "quality": { "visual": "全景路线完整、几何负担低；植被更有棱面，肢体分段较明显。", "motion": "完整绕行与拍翼鸟；轮转半径约偏小1.67%，轮底约5mm的小间距单独记录。", "environment": "5只关节拍翼鸟、3只鸭；黄昏、三视角、隐藏界面；没有明信片导出。", "selection": "未选为代表。原制作流程未完成实际浏览器WebGL检查；后续独立检查原交付通过，不把工具预览失败当作成品不能运行。" } }, { "id": "06", "label": "06 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第2次", "quality": { "visual": "角色有表情，编织车篮、花、包裹绳和围巾细节丰富；近景关节接缝仍可见。", "motion": "约170.82m闭合路线，弧长查表控制进度；轮转外半径一致，多圈检查连续。", "environment": "桥、邮局、船、6只拍翼鸟、7只鸭；黄昏、环境音、留影和三视角；没有蝴蝶。", "selection": "选为Sol标准代表及三个代表中的第2；用时的长失败请求不计入质量排名。" } }, { "id": "07", "label": "07 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Fast · 第3次", "quality": { "visual": "暖秋配色协调，角色、包裹和布料呈现较好；局部球形关节可见。", "motion": "围巾具有横向卷曲，尾巴持续形变。轮转半径0.55小于外半径0.593，理论角速度偏大约7.82%。", "environment": "桥、房屋、船、4只蝴蝶、4只鸭；没有飞鸟、前篮、黄昏和照片导出；相机按钮用于换视角。", "selection": "选为Fast代表及三个代表中的第3。布料、尾巴和低渲染负担有优势；路线、互动和运动精度仍有差距。" } }, { "id": "08", "label": "08 · GPT-6 Astra / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第3次", "quality": { "visual": "角色紧凑，包裹绑带与货架精细；表情和场景丰富程度不及03。", "motion": "正确外半径轮转，腿部跟随踏板；轮底约18mm小间距单列，不按拍摄角度判断大幅悬空。", "environment": "3只蝴蝶、5只关节拍翼鸟、3只鸭；有明信片，没有黄昏切换。", "selection": "比03快约8分49秒，但不按速度选片。保留03的综合视觉/功能；08的连续形变尾巴和更少三角形是优势。" } }, { "id": "09", "label": "09 · GPT-6.1 Sol / 极高（xhigh） · Standard · 第3次", "quality": { "visual": "连续曲面肢体让肘膝更顺滑，整座小岛清爽；角色和车篮等细节不及06。", "motion": "正确轮转外半径；120s加速绕行跨5次角度回绕，无位置跳变；路线用切线近似而非弧长查表。", "environment": "桥、邮局、花草和3只鸭；风力与黄昏可调；没有飞鸟、蝴蝶、前篮和留影。", "selection": "正常完成时间与02接近。仍选06，侧重角色表达、编织篮和环境互动；09的肢体连续性更好。" } } ] }